As the clash with Imu in One Piece approaches, a fan theory emerges suggesting that Luffy may join forces with his greatest foe for the ultimate battle.

Eiichiro Oda is meticulously addressing various plot threads as One Piece steadily heads toward its grand conclusion. Recently, Imu has stepped into the limelight, transitioning from a shadowy figure to a key player in the central narrative. Imu’s aggressive tactics indicate a dramatic shift, directly challenging pirates rather than operating behind the scenes, as evidenced by the fate of one of the Elders.

Luffy is destined to confront Imu eventually, but the question remains: is he adequately prepared? Despite being an emperor with awakened abilities, Luffy encountered challenges against the Elders. Given that Imu surpasses them in strength, Luffy may need to either attain new heights in power or ally with powerful partners.

One Piece Theory Suggests Luffy Might Join Forces with His Adversary

Blackbeard during his fight with Law | Credits: Studio Toei Animation

With the world in pursuit of the Straw Hats, determining who stands as ally or adversary is increasingly complex. Fans constantly devise theories speculating the trajectory of the One Piece storyline. One intriguing fan theory suggests that Luffy might ally with Blackbeard to take down Imu. This theory cleverly draws a parallel between the dynamic between Luffy and Blackbeard and that of Roger and Rocks.

Imu perceives both Luffy and Blackbeard as significant threats to their reign. The theory posits that where Roger faltered by never forming an alliance with Rocks, Luffy could rectify this by joining forces with Blackbeard. Their combined abilities could present an exhilarating plot twist, but how likely is this scenario?

Luffy and Blackbeard’s first meeting during Jaya | Credits: Studio Toei Animation

A compelling point favoring this theory is the initial encounter between Luffy and Blackbeard on Jaya, which underscored their shared beliefs amidst global mockery for their dreams. Since then, however, they have embarked on divergent paths. Luffy has remained committed to aiding others and building alliances, while Blackbeard has pursued ruthless self-interest at the expense of others.

As thrilling as a partnership between Luffy and Blackbeard sounds, it could represent a significant misstep in Eiichiro Oda’s One Piece.

Could This Alliance Be Oda’s Biggest Mistake?

A still of Luffy from Wano | Credits: Studio Toei Animation

Blackbeard’s lack of a moral compass reflects a character willing to sacrifice anyone for his ambitions. In contrast, Luffy embodies a more noble spirit. However, it’s important to acknowledge that both characters share the pirate ethos, which may pave the way for their unlikely collaboration. Nonetheless, Luffy’s loyalty to those he loves remains a cornerstone of his character, as demonstrated by his readiness to upheave the world for Ace’s sake.

Blackbeard has put many of Luffy’s loved ones in jeopardy, starting with Ace’s capture. He also disrespected Whitebeard during his demise by stealing his Devil Fruit. Recent threats toward Boa Hancock, Garp, and Koby amplify the stakes. If Luffy were to ally with Blackbeard, it would contradict the principles he stands for.

Garp and Luffy | Credits: Studio Toei Animation

Furthermore, if the climactic war targets the World Government, chaos comparable to the Marineford War is to be expected. Luffy boasts numerous allies ready to support him, eliminating the need for Blackbeard’s assistance. Ultimately, the satisfaction of watching Luffy decisively confront and defeat Blackbeard may serve as a stronger narrative choice than an alliance forged in adversity.